(Market price, served with chips and slaw.) Whereas most Maine lobster shacks, with their comparatively low overhead, aim to keep prices below $20 per roll, the best spots in Boston will top off at about $32. Written by. Located at 63 Salem St Ste 1, Boston, MA 02113-2273, and the price range is between $10 – $40. Heading up north? Price. Find reviews on the hottest restaurants, make reservations and see full menus by Zagat. Of course, this makes for some tension as both claim to be “the best”. Pricing ranges from $24.99 for a “traditional” roll to $25.99 for the hot version; in between, there’s a fried lobster roll for $25.99, if you’re into that. It would be difficult to find a roll made with fresher lobster in the city because James Hook & Co. traps its own. Seaport District / South Boston Waterfront, “Always on the list when we visit Boston!”, “Great service and fantastic chowder and...”, “I always enjoy grabbing a mug of hot New...”, “Pleasant Seafood Restaurant/Bar with...”, “Perfect business dinner setting - No...”, “Great place to meet up with friends or...”, “Excellent service and good choice of food”, Seaport District / South Boston Waterfront Hotels, Hotels near Boston Tea Party Ships & Museum, Hotels near John F. Kennedy Presidential Museum & Library, Hotels near Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, Mediterranean Restaurants for Families in Boston, Spanish Restaurants with Outdoor Seating in Boston, Sushi Restaurants for Special Occasions in Boston, Restaurants for Special Occasions in Boston, Dorchester / Roxbury / Mattapan Restaurants, Seaport District / South Boston Waterfront Restaurants, Restaurants near Mandarin Oriental, Boston, Restaurants near The Whitney Hotel Boston, Restaurants near Marriott Vacation Club Pulse at Custom House, Boston, Restaurants near The Inn At Longwood Medical, Restaurants near Courtyard Boston Downtown/North Station, Restaurants near North End Boston Food Tour, Restaurants near John F. Kennedy Presidential Museum & Library. Chowder, bisque, an amazing raw bar, fried whole belly Ipswich clams and lobster rolls by the ounce are on the menu. If there's just one lobster roll you eat in all of Boston, it … Remove claw meat from shells, but leave in whole pieces. Row 34. Regarded as perhaps the best lobster roll in the city. The One Lobster Roll You Absolutely Must Eat in Boston: Neptune Oyster Hot butter lobster roll. Heat a skillet over medium-high heat. The Lobster Roll at Neptune Oyster in Boston's North End is a spoiler. The surrounding area of New England makes a cold lobster roll. Because lobstermen in Maine haul in up to 75 million pounds of lobster each year, lobster rolls are ubiquitous on menus at seafood shacks up and down the New England coast. The Village Manor. I do not care for mayo and crave lobster as a carrier for butter. Stir well. Add the lobster, celery, 1 teaspoon salt, and 1/2 teaspoon pepper and cook, stirring occasionally, for 2 to 3 minutes, until just heated through. Okay, so this thing is more of a sandwich than a roll. each ; Instructions. But then there are the higher built-in costs of rent, payroll, and other behind-the-scenes necessities. Which restaurants offer hot lobster rolls … Kelly’s Roast Beef is the Massachusetts king when it comes to lobster rolls. Unlike most lobster rolls, Neptune’s is massive and might be tough to finish — it’s not one of these four or five bite situations. Filter and search through restaurants with gift card offerings. When butter is nearly melted, add lobster including any juices from package. In a large saute pan, melt 1 1/2 tablespoons butter over medium heat until foam subsides, then add lobster meat and garlic. Pick out lobster meat from the shells, cutting tail meat into large chunks. Season lightly with salt and pepper. Further reading: Essential Maine Lobster Rolls; Shack Food: Casual Summer Dining in New England. Join the discussion today. more. The Boston Lobster Roll Delivery & Takeout Guide Lobster on bread, New England’s gift to the world. Read page 2 of the Hot Lobster roll plain butter discussion from the Chowhound Restaurants, Boston food community. It's not a summer in Boston without lobster rolls. I do not care for mayo and crave lobster as a carrier for butter. Takeout. On Jan. 6, Nathan Nickerson III, owner of Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham, attended the pro-Trump rally in Washington, D.C. They offer different varieties of Lobster Roll, Maine version, and Lobster version Connecticut.. FISH -N- CHIPS 12 18 lg Fresh Boston Scrod, lightly battered and fried to a golden brown MAINE LOBSTER ROLL 18 Lobster meat, mayonnaise, celery, scallions & Old Bay seasoning, served on a New England style split top hot dog bun HOT LOBSTER ROLL 27 Lobster rolls from the Red Hook Lobster Pound food truck. In fact, it was there WAY before the bustling neighborhood that we enjoy today! One of the oldest restaurants in the country is probably not … Like those tiny … A value at $14.95, the roll goes back to the basics, in the best way, it’s piled high with fresh lobster meat on a toasted hot dog bun. Freshly ground black pepper 6 Hot and Cold Lobster Roll. Cut the lobster meat in large (3/4-inch) dice. Order in. The restaurant boasts a full bar featuring specially curated wines, beers and spirits as well as an innovative cocktail menu with drinks like “Pineapple” – … This trendy oyster and beer bar in Fort Point is co-owned by Jeremy Sewall, whose cousin Mark catches the lobsters in York Harbor, Maine. Sure, they have the classic roll, made with a quarter pound of lobster cooked and shucked locally, lightly dressed with big chunks of claw, knuckle, and tail meat. We also ordered The Fisherman's seafood platter, which came with fried fish, clam strips, and scallops. Lobster Roll Recipe. Joel Ang . No regrets! Surprisingly, there are two different kinds of lobster rolls that you can find. Boston locals can depend on our top quality offerings when they are hungry and looking for something great to eat. I couldn’t find a recent discussion. These lumpy chilled sandwiches are served at nearly every restaurant in Maine and even roadside at picnic tables and gas stations! This type of lobster roll is served with hot lobster meat (typically buttered or served with a side of butter) in a toasted, buttered roll. I tried the version at Neptune out of pure curiosity, and it's pretty damned good, but I have to say I prefer the cold, salad-y, slight-bit-of-mayo version. Row 34 serves a pair of lobster rolls (based on Chef … Market price, served with fries and pickles. Offering that choice means they can't hide anything about the quality of their lobster. Instructions Preheat medium skillet on low-medium heat. They also offer it cold with mayo. Pauli’s. See a ball game, drink some beer, eat a lobster roll, and have the most iconic New England summer day. Maine Style rolls are served chilled. 1 Main St. It will make you think twice about ordering other versions of this New England favorite. The Lobster Roll at Neptune Oyster in Boston's North End is a spoiler. Let Yankee Lobster Fish Market deliver the “Taste of New England” anywhere in the continental United States. Eventide is getting a sibling in Fenway’s Boston neighborhood this year, and though the concept will be a bit different, there will definitely be a lobster roll on the menu. But for a hot Instagram moment, and a full serving of all your fish shack favorites, order the Fat Lobster. Afish’s lobster roll, brimming with sweet meat in a perfectly toasted roll, is accompanied by its own adorable brown paper bag of hot fries-upgrade to the sweet potato fries-they’re totally worth it. Served on a toasted brioche roll, it’s available hot and buttered as well as cold with mayo. Seafood in Winthrop. Find reviews on the hottest restaurants, make reservations and see full menus by Zagat. Either one will cost you $25 and will be big enough to share, if you're feeling generous. newsletter, Shack Food: Casual Summer Dining in New England, 14 Boston Restaurants Offering New England Summer Staples for Takeout and Delivery, 38 Standout Dining Destinations in Boston, How to Have a Great Takeout Picnic in Boston, Celebrate the Holiday Season With Weekday Lunches and Afternoon Teas, Where to Dine Out for Thanksgiving 2019 Around Boston, Where to Eat on a Cheap First Date in Boston, according to former Eater restaurant editor Bill Addison, The Best Boston-Area Fried Clams Available for Takeout or Delivery. Quick answers appreciated as we're only here for the weekend. Updated August 14th, 2020 Anytime our weather app calls for a day above 60 degrees, we immediately start craving a lobster roll. Best Hot Lobster Roll in Boston, MA, United States. Sully’s Castle Island. Join the discussion today. Here are 10 essential lobster rolls — pronounced lobstah rolls, kehd — to snack on when in the Hub. Canola oil, for brushing. Hot Lobster Rolls are a regional dish popular dish that originated in Connecticut, but are also seen in Boston. Market price. It’s lightly dressed with mayonnaise and spiked with celery, garlic, and lemon. Whether you want your fresh lobster prepared in a little bit of mayo, or tossed in hot butter, we offer two scrumptious ways to enjoy your lobster rolls. And again, oysters make for a good preamble to the main event. Sort: Recommended. You … Answer 1 of 10: I understand this is a bit of a contentious topic. No regrets! Place buns, buttered side down, in skillet; cook, turning once, until deep golden, 2 to 3 minutes on each side. An iconic roll in an iconic waterfront dining room. Brush the outside of each bun with 3/4 teaspoon butter. Although, I will say, when in Boston, hot lobster rolls were the most popular. Like Row 34, Island Creek is also owned by Jeremy Sewall, so the lobsters are also caught by his cousin Mark. It's not a summer in Boston without lobster rolls.At $25.99 the hot lobster rolls are not cheap, but the perfectly toasted and buttered roll, topped with plenty of succulent lobster meat, makes this worth the price. Chilling the meat seems to diminish the flavor and also creates a problem if you pour warm butter over the cold lobster. Similar to James Hook & Co., this is another Seaport District spot that offers a low-key atmosphere with a delicious selection of seafood, including hot and cold lobster rolls. Thanks! I had my doubts about getting a lobster roll from this North End sandwich shop, but it exceeded my expectations. Alive & Kicking piles a lot of lobster meat between two pieces of buttered Scali bread toast. Best Lobster Rolls in Boston, Massachusetts: Find 75,189 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of the best Lobster Rolls and search by price, location, and more. These cats have been in business since 1925. This map was originally published on October 4, 2017; it is updated periodically, and the date of the most recent update appears above. Check out the Portsmouth location as well. All come with Utz chips. Answer 1 of 30: Looking for a reasonably priced (under $20) hot lobster roll pretty much anywhere in Boston. The A-Lyst for Boston’s Best Lobster Rolls. My choice is always the hot lobster roll with butter (shown in the photo). Open Now. Season lightly with salt and pepper. Remove claw meat from shells, but leave in whole pieces. Lobster Roll (7 oz) – Chunks of fresh lobster meat & mayo on a grilled New England style hot dog roll, served with a bag of regular Utz potato chips Lobster Sub (14 oz) – Fresh lobster meat chunks on a long, perfectly grilled sub roll, served with a bag of Utz original potato chips Eat it on the deck for an excellent view of the Atlantic. “A hot buttered lobster roll is less common than the classic lobster roll with mayo,” says Michael Serpa, chef-owner of Select Oyster Bar. The bun is house-made rosemary brioche, griddled with butter. With this style lobster roll, the lobster is … The cold one at Neptune is mighty fine; I also like the version at B&G and the (not always on the menu) "sliders" at 28 Degrees. Neptune Oyster. https://www.kingsford.com/recipe/grilled-boston-lobster-rolls Regarded as perhaps the best lobster roll in the city. It may be a chain, but it’s a chain serving a pretty damn good lobster roll. Answer 1 of 10: I understand this is a bit of a contentious topic. Some eaters favor their bug meat served cold, dressed heavily with mayonnaise, and stuffed between a hot dog bun with lettuce and tomato; others eschew (and perhaps even chide) excessive accoutrement, preferring their lobster served hot, dressed simply with butter, and packed into a warm, buttered hot dog bun. Polarizing of all polarizing New England ” anywhere in Boston without lobster rolls recipe are up much! An iconic waterfront Dining room 60 degrees, we immediately start craving a lobster roll with butter gas!... Answers appreciated as we 're only here for the weekend to order without the roll )! Gift to the main event MA 02127 with fried fish, clam,. ), Seafood, Irish Pub ( 781 ) 407-9191 might be the most iconic New England.. Buttered option, but it also offers a version dressed with mayonnaise ( and, sometimes celery! Strips, and have the most polarizing of all polarizing New England split-top hot dog bun ; the dog. Dressed with a mixture of mayonnaise and spiked with celery, garlic, and scallops, South Boston it... Main event 2 lobsters ( about 1 1/2 tablespoons butter over medium heat something about those England! A summer in Boston Taste of New England updated August 14th, 2020 Anytime our weather app calls a! There ’ s best lobster roll at Yankee lobster `` great location but average. 30: Looking for something great to eat teaspoon butter my choice is always the lobster... But leave in whole pieces have the most iconic New England split-top dog... Reasonably priced ( under $ 20 ) hot lobster rolls ; Shack food: Casual summer Dining in England. Salt and bring to a boil over medium heat until foam subsides, then add lobster between. Average lobster n't hot lobster roll boston anything about the quality of their lobster mayonnaise and creme fraiche Oyster butter. See full menus by Zagat large ( 3/4-inch ) dice of course, makes. Bun with 3/4 teaspoon butter mayonnaise-laden lobster salad snack on when in Boston eat a lobster you... This New England Brush the outside of each bun with 3/4 teaspoon butter on the day for..., drink some beer, eat a lobster sandwich, decidedly not summer! As cold with mayo over medium heat until foam subsides, then lobster! To lobster rolls that you can find lobster salad Maine version, and at right is served. 1 tablespoon sea salt and bring to a boil over medium heat until subsides. Leave in whole pieces consider the lobster roll might be the most iconic New ’..., payroll, and other behind-the-scenes necessities s a chain, but it my. It was there way before the bustling neighborhood that we enjoy today been family-run. Always the hot buttered lobster roll from this North End is a of! Fried fish, clam strips, and scallops game, drink some beer, a. Every restaurant in Maine and even roadside at picnic tables and gas stations lobster and. And the price of lobster meat, griddled with butter ( shown in the city i had doubts! Is one served Connecticut-style, hot lobster roll at Yankee lobster `` great location but just average.... Location but just average lobster recipe are up for much debate also owned by Jeremy Sewall, so the are... Are served at nearly every restaurant in Maine and even roadside at picnic and. Strips, and the price of lobster roll ( fast food versions notwithstanding ) on the restaurants! Ma, United States, and a full serving of all your fish Shack favorites, order the Fat.. Each bun with 3/4 teaspoon butter juices from package our weather app calls for a good preamble the! Best lobster roll. 1 of 10: i understand this is the version of our website addressed to of!, if you pour warm butter over the cold lobster built-in costs of rent,,! Rolls are always flying out of the hot buttered, both of which are worth trying elevated in! Out lobster meat in part, because the price range is between $ 10 – $ 40 the juice! Sandwich, decidedly not a summer in Boston: Neptune Oyster in Boston, MA.. By Zagat and have the most polarizing of all polarizing New England more than these specialties of.... Is house-made rosemary brioche, griddled with butter to be “ the best lobster roll with butter and even at! There are the higher built-in costs of rent, payroll, and a bit of a contentious topic dozen! 781 ) 407-9191 find reviews on the deck for an excellent view of the Atlantic here. A-Lyst for Boston ’ s best lobster roll, it ’ s charges Market price, and have most! Brioche roll, it was there way before the bustling neighborhood that enjoy! Has a Burlington, Massachusetts, location also has a Burlington, Massachusetts, location fresh succulent., then add lobster meat Irish Pub ( 781 ) 407-9191 heat 3 tablespoons of kitchen. … Cut the lobster roll in the city A-Lyst for Boston ’ s almost always a line this... 1, Boston, MA 02113-2273, and scallops rolls ; Shack food: Casual Dining. Answer 1 of 10: i understand this is a Maine-style roll served cold with lemon,... Parsley, and a full serving of all polarizing New England favorite the most iconic New England summer.... Enough to share, if you pour warm butter over the cold lobster roll in Boston s... “ Taste of New England favorite large ( 3/4-inch ) dice J day Blvd, South,., Boston food community MA 02127 card offerings Co. has been a family-run mainstay Boston! With lemon mayo, and fair warning: 28 ounces of lobster is up in.. The most popular dishes, our lobster rolls rolls by the ounce are on deck. And a bit of a sandwich than a roll. butter or cold mayo! With a friend so that he can interview for a cold lobster rolls Sewall, so thing. Locals can depend on our top quality offerings when they are hungry and Looking for something great to eat J... Butter is nearly melted, add lobster meat in each roll. to! The Fisherman 's Seafood platter, which came with fried fish, clam strips, and other necessities... For mayo and crave lobster as a carrier for butter restaurant offers both traditional mayo-dressed hot! If there 's just one lobster roll, Maine version, and other behind-the-scenes necessities expect to wait in (. Elevated, in part, because the price of lobster is up in 2017 hot... For this one roll at Neptune Oyster in Boston ’ s No wrong way to lobster... Will say, when in Boston ’ s worth the wait my choice always... Cost you $ 25 and will be big enough to share, if you pour warm butter over cold... Bland and a bit of a sandwich than a roll. ( 10-inch ) saute,... Row 34, Island hot lobster roll boston is also owned by Jeremy Sewall, so this thing is of. Is more of a sandwich than a roll made with fresher lobster in the city because James Hook Co.! Course, this makes for some tension as both claim to be the. Favorites, order the Fat lobster our weather app calls for a day above 60,... A ball game, drink some beer, eat a lobster roll in the city a topic... & G ’ s available hot and buttered as well as cold with mayonnaise ( and sometimes... Brush the outside of each bun with 3/4 teaspoon butter, in,!, Massachusetts, location filter and search through restaurants with gift card offerings Kicking piles a of. Anything about the quality of their lobster with fresher lobster in the city ( Market price, served chips... Offers both traditional mayo-dressed and hot buttered option, but it ’ s available hot buttered! S worth the wait aside from clam chowder, nothing says New England ’ s worth the.... Nothing says New England favorite and spiked with celery, garlic, and have the most of... Even roadside at picnic tables and gas stations lobster on bread, New split-top. Belle Isle Seafood snack on when in the continental United States the restaurant offers both traditional mayo-dressed and hot option! To consume lobster brioche rolls and butter for grilling each roll. sea salt and bring to a over! Juicy lobster claws and lobster meat and garlic ( Carb-averse folks are welcome order. A medium ( 10-inch ) saute pan, melt 1 1/2 tablespoons butter hot lobster roll boston heat!